Natural Consequences

Lynda Runge • February 21, 2025

Helping Children Learn Through Experience—Without Blame, Shame, or Rescue

Natural consequences are the outcomes that occur naturally, without adult interference. When you stand in the rain, you get wet. When you skip a meal, you feel hungry. When you forget your coat, you get cold. Allowing children to experience these consequences helps them develop essential self-help skills.

For example, I can remind my child every day to grab their coat, and they may only remember when I prompt them. But if they forget their coat and experience the cold firsthand, they’re more likely to remember it next time. That real-life experience often teaches the lesson more effectively than constant reminders.

However, how we handle these situations as adults matters. It’s important to avoid piggybacking—adding unnecessary blame, shame, or pain. Comments like "I told you so!" or scolding a child for their mistake shift the focus from learning to defending against criticism.

Children naturally feel bad when they make mistakes; they want to do better. When we pile on guilt, we diminish the learning experience, as the child becomes preoccupied with their emotions rather than reflecting on their actions.

How Should Parents Respond?

Show Empathy and Understanding
Acknowledge the child’s experience with kindness:

"It must have been tough to go hungry (get wet, get that bad grade, lose your bicycle)."

When appropriate, offer encouragement: "I love you and believe you can handle this."

Avoid Rescuing or Fixing Everything
It can be difficult for parents to step back, but allowing children to navigate challenges fosters resilience. By experiencing both successes and setbacks, they develop confidence in their ability to handle life’s ups and downs.

By responding with empathy and avoiding unnecessary interference, we give children the opportunity to grow, learn, and develop true independence.

October 23, 2025
The Science of Reading at St. James – Implementation & Growth
October 8, 2025
At St. James, we believe that raising thoughtful, resilient children is a shared journey between educators, counselors, and families. As part of our intentional approach to supporting students in a rapidly changing digital world, Dr. Hannah Meineke, St. James Spanish teacher and school counselor, launched a new Parent-Staff-Faculty Book Club this year to explore “The Anxious Generation” by Jonathan Haidt.
September 24, 2025
To help families better understand the progression from preschool through kindergarten, the chart below outlines the age-based pathways and schedule options available at St. James.
September 9, 2025
Meet Our Expanded Counseling Team
By St. James Lutheran School Parents August 28, 2025
Advice for New Families at St. James Lutheran School
August 27, 2025
Welcome to Mini Mavericks: A Space for Caregiver-Child Connection and Creative Exploration! September 11 - Welcome Back!
June 11, 2025
At St. James, we believe our school is more than just a place of learning—it's a community where children and families are known, supported, and loved. We recently asked our parents a simple question: “What do you love most about St. James?” Their responses speak volumes about the environment we strive to cultivate every day. Here’s what they shared—
May 21, 2025
Summer is almost here, and at St. James, we’re gearing up for a season packed with fun, learning, and community connection! Check out the exciting events and opportunities happening this summer:
April 28, 2025
St. James Lutheran School in Lincoln Park unveils a major expansion with two new middle school classrooms, a renovated gymnasium, and more. Learn how this growth supports the school’s mission of Christ-centered education and serves the community.
By Lynda Runge March 24, 2025
Are You Asking or Telling? The Key to Empowering Your Child